At the launch of season seven of the Hyundai A-League, the new inclusive campaign "We are Football" was rolled out with much fanfare - a campaign to "empower fans and make them proud of their league".

In the words of Lyall Gorman, head of the A-League, it was "a call for unity, for the football family to come together as one".

Someone it seems, forgot to copy Clive Palmer in on that memo.

Football fans have been left reeling in the wake of Palmer’s sensational comments - some disappointed, some disillusioned and others disgusted that an owner of one of 'their' clubs - be it bottom of the table or not, should dismiss it - and the game, as insignificant.

Of course, as the man bankrolling Gold Coast United, Clive Palmer is entitled to say whatever he thinks (he says his comments were misconstrued incidentally - a claim that passionate football fans may find hard to swallow). Conducting his exclusive media interview on Monday night wearing a "come play" scarf - a relic of Australia's failed world cup bid, was also a rather unusual choice to say the least.

However, Palmer is a businessman and he didn't become the richest man in Queensland by being ‘Mr. Popular’. He has his own ideas and opinions. A salient point he raises is the fact that he is not the only disgruntled owner.

This is an issue that needs to be addressed.

The general consensus seems to be that in an ideal world all the key roles in this game would be filled with 'proper football people'.

For now though, the ones willing to stump up millions of their own hard-earned are not always from football backgrounds, and quite frankly, beggars can't be choosers.

While the A-League is beholden to cashed-up individuals, they are always likely to be at the whim of human nature.

Nobody is suggesting that the wealth controlling the game should be pandered to without reservation, but it certainly appears that communication needs to be improved, and a common, transparent path negotiated.

Ideas from different backgrounds should be heard, respected and where appropriate embraced, not marginalised.

Recently, the clamour has been for traditional members of the football community to have their voices heard - but new members of the football family should also be welcomed - and, where there is a genuine desire to help the progression of the game, given a chance to prove their worth, regardless of the shape of their preferred 'football'.

Sydney FC CEO Dirk Melton has first-hand experience of the code jump and has fallen head over heels in love with the round ball, while still retaining his ongoing passion for the game of Rugby League.

Melton sees football as "one of the greatest conduits to social change in the world".

Yet despite his ongoing fight to put the former champion on a firmer footing and engage the club with the broader community (through initiatives such as the partnerships with 'Beyond Blue' and UNICEF), he still experiences vitriol from those who see him as an interloper.

Glenn Elliott used to kick a Sherrin around, yet could regularly be seen in the 'cheap seats' at Hindmarsh as a fan of Adelaide United, until his appointment as CEO of the club repositioned him in the corporate box.

Elliott believes a cross-fertilisation of ideas appeals to all sports. On the field, he says the creation of space and playing a possession game is something all coaches strive to achieve, and it's no surprise that ideas from one code permeate across to others.

Off the pitch, he observes that a crowd at Hindmarsh on any given day would contain a large spread of both Crows and Port supporters. "Adelaide people" he says, "know how important all these teams are to our community".

Elliot says the biggest challenge facing our code is to present a consolidated front. The game - he believes - has to have a voice if it is to work with government, attract funding and secure high level partnerships. Unity in the industry works better politically.

However, while most newcomers appear to have the best of intentions, they would be well-advised to remember the need to engage on a football level. The game has a proud history in this country that the football family want acknowledged. Most fans are too educated in the game to be taken for fools and few see 'crowds' of 2,000 at an A-League match as acceptable - no matter what the per capita ratio says.

The drama surrounding Gold Coast United has resembled a Shakespearean tragedy - passionate outbursts, unrequited love, vitriolic hate and a few disembodied heads rolling around. While the actors are, for the most part, still on the stage, let's hope it does not end in a tragic death.

There is no doubt that Clive Palmer's comments were a dagger in the heart to those of us who love the game and want it to thrive.

But it's also perhaps a timely reminder that if 'we are football', then 'we' should stand shoulder to shoulder and be truly united.

 
Poll
Which will be the Qantas Socceroos' toughest game?


Comments (12)
 
I would like to see the FFA run more of the teams so they can see just how hard the job is that some of these owners have. It is fairly easy to sit back and put forward a decree that the owners have to live by but another thing to make an a-league team anything but a bottomless pit for money.
jason  |  
27 Feb 2012 06:10 PM
 
 
...and airing its dirty linen in public is the last thing that football needs. This public slanging match between the FFA and GCU is childish in the extreme, and does no credit whatsoever to either party. Deal with these sorts of things in private.
Jonny  |  
26 Feb 2012 11:22 AM
 
 
The worst thing of all is this stuff hogging headlines. The only thing that really matters is what happens on the pitch. Administrators, owners, and other types that like to power dress leave me stone cold. They just need to understand that their role is to facilitate what happens on the pitch. We don't need their little "Freedom of Speech power games. THe GC coach had it spot on today when he said Oh were the shirts different
Geoff  |  
26 Feb 2012 07:24 AM
 
 
There seems a mindset in the FFA in the past. 1. Here the FAA has major billionaire client, Mr Palmer and is falling out with him. In my business I would be assigning my best man to look after him with that money. Sure fans are not going to the Gold Coast but we have had a team for several years paid for a lot by Mr Palmer. Do whatever we can to keep him happy and those others investing in our clubs as well. Talk to them and do it, dont antagonise them. 2. All this pull together stuff above sounds like the sort of motherhood statements that lead to more motherhood statements not success. Where will football be in 30 years, I venture look back 30 years and extrapolate from then to now and forward. Here is some- forget about gates at stadia, fill the stadia with poor people at Clive Palmers a donation to a charity prices, concentrate on sponsorship, if a shirt has to say the local sex shop no problems as long as the pay big time, dont worry about Free Speech logos - indeed in an election Vote Labor might be appropriate if they will pay.-Organise real days out for rich fans, meet the chairman, meet the players, lunch or dinner, and a big ticket price- Get in teams from Indonesia and Malaysia- ignore FIFA bring in goal line technology- widen the goals so that 3-3 is a common result, join up with AFL and Rugby clubs- Tinkler is a genius- put a camera in the ball- make a dating agency for young people at the game via a web page-Subsidise an Indigenous team out of Darwin or N Queensland- approach Noel Pearson to be Chairman, get an Indigenous Development Grant- I have not even started to think yet but the FFA- how can they possibly lose money in the biggest sport in the world.
Michael Wilson  |  
26 Feb 2012 01:52 AM
 
 
waste of time stevo - FFA have their heads deep in the sand and only believe what they want to believe
Mrs 'Obbs  |  
24 Feb 2012 03:17 PM
 
 
I hope that FFA HQ are reading comments from fans on this really important topic. Not just here but on other football web sites. Simply put, if FFA is happy to have private owners effectively fund the A-league clubs then it needs to allow the owners a say in how the A-league is run. No getting away from this issue. Clive has the support of other owners even if some think he may have over done the public rhetoric.
Stevo  |  
23 Feb 2012 09:30 PM
 
 
One thing I would like to see is journalists and commentators talking up the A-League and Australian football rather than talking it down. This continual nit-picking, analysis and introspection is not what we need. Try seeing the glass as half full and not half empty for a change. The A-League is what we are and what we have. We are not Europe or anywhere else, and we have to do what we can with what we have. The FFA is making changes and trying to improve things. Sure, it's made some mistakes, but remember that the only people who do not make mistakes are those that don't do anything in the first place. Let's keep working towards more football, more clubs, better football, better players, and bigger crowds. And be positive despite the hiccups along the way.
JW  |  
23 Feb 2012 11:54 AM
 
 
The GCU set-up has not worked. The Gold Coast population profile looks to be totally opposite to that required to build and sustain a football platform. The A-League is based on a salary cap. Rich owners who live in these areas cannot, no matter how hard they try buy a Premiership (which is a great thing). I would think that nobody wants to end up with a lop-sided EPL set-up. Its not the Australian way. The FFA must review their performance criteria when awarding team entry into the A-League - obvously there are three main areas eligible for A-League status - outer Sydney, the ACT and Tassie. I for one, would think the A-League is certainly open to further expansion with credibility. I also think that the A-League is not promoted as well as it could be. The A-League Highlights program is a very professional, positive product for A-League exposure and, very suitable for any commercial platform in Australia. It must be seen by kids who can't access Fox - there are a lot of them - more, I would suggest than the FFA's estimates. These are the people the FFA need to encourage to go to a game with thier parents. One minor point. I for one am not happy with the content of the FoxSports FC program - its become to negative and spends much more time these days covering problem areas without knowing the full facts. I consider this detrimental to the games promotion. You only need to look at Episode 1 - Topic 1 as an example. Fox promoited this program non-stop before Rd1 as the best A-League season ever - only for viewers to be immediatekly confronted with A-League problems - not a good look.
Paul Fisher  |  
23 Feb 2012 11:31 AM
 
 
Poll: Or Liam Miller at Glory - a real asset to that organisation.
pete  |  
22 Feb 2012 09:33 PM
 
 
Steph, you are absolutely right. The game in Australia is far too divided, and fans seem to want to engage in a war of codes. What for? We should aim for our game to be as good as it can. However many spectators League, Union, AFL and Cricket get should not be of concern to us. What is to say at a passionate AFL fan would not attend a game of football, or record it to watch it after the AFL is finished on TV? In my opinion we should be aiming much higher than conquering the Australian market alone. If we improve the quality of our football through incesant focus on youth development and great coaching we can then expand. The English Premier League does not depend solely on England for it's revenue. England have 51.446 million people, but they sell their game everywhere, much like Spain and Italy do. We have South East Asia, with India and China making up over 36% of the world's population. So, let us get united and pull together, we could become the world's most watched league. Is it possible? Well, are we Australian? To us nothing is beyond possibility.
Christian Bitancurt  |  
22 Feb 2012 03:23 PM
 
 
The reality is people are trying to expedite change and while many would argue the speed of change is not happening quick enough we should hope that a new transparency is embraced in the sport. Unification comes through communication , dialogue and understanding of the problems so to this point the owners should hope the FFA is listening. The change should occur from an understanding of potentially any idea raised in the Football Family . People hope that the football monolith takes hold with a respect of what needs to be done and a sound strategy to go forward with a view to the future. wait and see.
Tony  |  
22 Feb 2012 10:15 AM
 
 
What about Broich in the poll?
Dave McDaniel  |  
21 Feb 2012 02:45 PM