Branko Culina
 
 
 
 

Former Newcastle Jets and Sydney FC coach Branko Culina joins footballaustralia.com.au as an occasional columnist, focusing on coaching issues and tactical trends.

Over the past decade, the 4-2-3-1 has emerged as the world's most popular formation, but it doesn't suit everyone. Here in the Hyundai A-League, plenty of teams use it, but not all of them succeed with it.

In my view, Brisbane Roar, Newcastle Jets and Perth Glory are the clubs who this season can expect to get the most out of a system that allows them to play a possession-based game with the emphasis on quick counter-attacking. Why? Because of they've got the players to make it work. More on that later.

At international level, Spain, Germany and The Netherlands are just some of the top countries to use the system. At club level, Real Madrid, Bayern Munich, Chelsea, Borussia Dortmund and Manchester City have all had great success with this formation in recent years.

The Qantas Socceroos have also used it for the best part of seven years - ever since Guus Hiddink arrived just prior to the 2006 World Cup. Perhaps because of Hiddink's influence, almost all the A-League clubs play it now.

So why has the 4-2-3-1 become so popular? For me it's because of its flexibility. You can revert to a 4-4-2, a 4-3-3 or even a 4-5-1 - depending on the flow of the game - without greatly interrupting the structure and personnel.

The system suits teams who have a genuine no.10 who can also play as second striker, although I personally believe the modern playmaker is more likely to be the no.6 because he has more time and space to influence the game.

Which brings me to my point: while most teams in the A-League play the system well and have some quality players in key positions, Brisbane, Perth and Newcastle have the best overall balance to get the maximum out of the formation.

The three key positions are no.6 (controlling midfielder/distributor), no.10 (playmaker) and no.9 (striker/goalscorer). Our competition is blessed with some outstanding no.10s in Alessandro Del Piero, Mitch Nichols, Dario Vidosic, Tom Rogic, Fred, Shinji Ono and Marcos Flores.

However, the key to this system is the right balance around the no.10, where the support of a good controlling midfielder and a strong targetman or mobile goal scoring striker make all the difference. That's why the Roar, the Jets and the Glory have a lot to look forward to this season.

Brisbane have a ball-winner and good distributor in Erik Paartalu in controlling midfield, a clever playmaker in Mitch Nichols, a mobile striker and goalscoring freak in Besart Berisha.

The Roar also have the added bonus of having Thomas Broich who is equally comfortable in a number of key positions, while attacking fullbacks Ivan Franjic and Shane Stefanutto can - on their day - be unplayable.

Perth Glory’s central midfield of Jacob Burns and Liam Miller is also very good. Burns provides work rate and ball winning attributes while Miller’s passing ability is second to none. McGarry is a good player but not a no.10 - in my view the Glory would do better if he swapped roles with Miller. Up front in Shane Smeltz they have a strong skilful and prolific goalscorer.

Newcastle may lack a little bit of quality in key positions but to me they are the best counter attacking team using this formation in the A-League.

In the centre of midfield they have two solid controlling midfielders in Ruben Zadkovich and Jobe Wheelhouse, very quick and mobile fullbacks in Dominik Ritter and Scott Neville, while Craig Goodwin and James Virgili have the speed and dribbling ability to complement their best asset - the strength of the target man Emile Heskey and intelligence of Ryan Griffiths.

Of course it's not only about what you do in possession, but also how well you work without the ball.

The 4-2-3-1 formation is very flexible when the opposition has the ball. Depending on the state of the game, you can set up your team to defend with one player in attack, five in midfield and four in defence or two in attack, four in midfield and four in defence.

Mobile teams like Brisbane and Newcastle have an added advantage - they can defend with lines of three strikers, three midfielders and four defenders, and can therefore regain possession high in the opposition half.

Having said the 4-2-3-1 is about the players, and different coaches use it in different ways. Tactically-smart coaches like Graham Arnold have shown they can adjust the system during the game without changing too much to the structure or the personnel.

However the bottom line is that it works best when you have quality players in key positions, which is why I believe Brisbane, Newcastle and Perth have an edge over the rest.

 
The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author, and do not reflect those of Football Federation Australia.
Poll
Who is Australia's best young prospect?






Comments (10)
 
hi im a massive spurs fan also a roar fan from england.spurs have been playing diff formations all season and its only worked now and then with 1 man up front but its only working with a 4-4-2 formation its the way falward also when harry redknapp took over spurs where botton of the prem he took us to 6th in the first season keep the faith roar fans see you in the den 21 dec
neil  |  
10 Nov 2012 08:41 AM
 
 
@DENNIS - I think it's difficult to pigeon-hole Messi or Ronaldo at least from that list. I wouldn't call either the playmakers from their teams. they tend to make space and get on the end of great passing from their teammates and seem to have a licence to roam wherever they please. At Barca at least, the players swap roles so much you can't pigeon-hole them into a certain role, but from what I've seen this season, Xavi tends to play that 6 role a lot, and Cesc is their 10. He';s always getting that ball around the box and feeding Messi, or the wingers. Messi does this too, as does Iniesta, Pedro etc etc, but to a lesser extent.
Hamish  |  
4 Nov 2012 04:26 PM
 
 
top article, always enjoy some quality tactical analysis! cheers Branko
dl  |  
4 Nov 2012 02:21 PM
 
 
Great to hear your thought again Branko and what a terrific person you are. I will be interested to see your thoughts on both the Sky Blues and Jets this season. Plus your thoughts on Holger Osieck with the Socceroos.
Stuart John Pearson Jets Member 4151  |  
3 Nov 2012 07:33 PM
 
 
I agree with the other Benjamin of BNE in that Nichols is not our creative outlet - except on occasion - and Broich controls the majority of this area. With Eric close behind. And Bes, I think these are the areas that Rado is changing this season. The occasional long ball from Theo and more forward passes are the hallmarks of this season so far. Remember Bes's first against MV, 3 kicks 'keeper to goal. And the quick outlets, particularly through Halloran have us past most of the opposition before they know what's coming. Hopefully we'll just get a bit better at it, and a bit less predictable, as the season progresses.
Ben of BNE  |  
2 Nov 2012 12:04 PM
 
 
Branco , that's why you are not a coach anymore , when reading your article. 1. The playmakers of now are the wing players and not 6 or 10 , that was in the past . Look at Ronaldo , Messi , Ribery and before Zidane , they all play from the wings , because in that area you still have a chance for 1:1 without facing 2 or 3 defenders. 2. You talk about the past decade but Barcelona and Ajax played this system already in the seventies , another proof of your lack of knowledge 3.You mentioned also the strong targetman , this is also from the old days , in modern football the targetman doesn't exist anymore , modern football is based on rotation , making space and penetration , no static positions 4.That's why the A-League is still 10 years behind the European style of modern football with coaches like you All the best with studying modern football..............................................
Dennis  |  
2 Nov 2012 05:37 AM
 
 
Best format to control the midfield, can be attacking and sufficient numbers to defend. Only down side, lack of freedom for creative players...eg Kaka
Andrew Chalet  |  
1 Nov 2012 02:15 PM
 
 
Branko: I was very intertested in your comment: Brisbane Roar... can expect to get the most out of a system that allows them to play a possession-based game with the emphasis on quick counter-attacking. I wish!! Brisbane definately play a posession-based game, but have not launched a quick counter attack in the past 2 and a bit years!! And it drives us - the dedicated fans- right up the wall. Every opposition knows 2 things about Brisbane: 1. They can use as many players as they like to come at Brisbane in an attack, becuase they know with absolutely certainty that even if they lose the ball, Brisbane will take 15 minutes and 12 sideways passes to get anywhere near their penalty box and 2. When the opposition lose the ball - not only do they have a good 5 minutes to get back, but once they get back - have a cut lunch while they wait for Brisbanes attack to arrive - they can camp in 2 solid lines in their penalty box with absolute impunity and let Brisbane pass it pass and forth all night because they know that noone in Brisbane will take a shot from outside the box! Why oh why oh why on both counts?
BES  |  
1 Nov 2012 02:02 PM
 
 
Branko you must be looking at Mitch Nichols through some very rose coloured glasses. I have been a fan and season ticket holder for the past 5 season since moving to Brisbane. How can you call him an outstanding number 10? How can you even call him a number 10? Broich does most of the creative work in the Brisbane team but does play too wide to be a true number 10. Totally agree with your comments about Paartalu, Berisha, Stefanutto and the outstanding Franjic. Nichols runs around a lot, and gets into some good positions to score some good goals at some crucial times but passing and especially creating are not his strengths.
Benjamin  |  
1 Nov 2012 12:44 PM
 
 
Branco, very insightful article, great to read the thought patterms of a professional coach. Also nice to see your not lost from the Football world in Australia.
MH of Kellyville  |  
1 Nov 2012 11:36 AM
 

Branko Culina

Former Newcastle Jets and Sydney FC coach Branko Culina joins footballaustralia.com.au as an occasional columnist, focusing on coaching issues and tactical trends.