Paul Johnson
 
 
 
 

With Alex Wilkinson signing a deal with Jeonbuk Hyundai Motors in Korea and joining the growing brigade of Aussie players moving to Asia, Central Coast Mariners have been left short of a long-term servant and a great club captain.

The reason Wilko took the deal? Money, plain and simple. This Asian opportunity offers him the chance to set himself up for life, in a career that is shorter than most and no one can begrudge him that - but how the Mariners adjust to life without him on the pitch remains to be seen.

Mariners boss Graham Arnold admitted he was disappointed to lose his captain, but said the opportunity for Wilkinson to set himself up financially is one the player couldn’t refuse.

“Alex has been a great servant for this club for a very long time and we are disappointed to see him go, but at the moment Australian clubs simply cannot compete with the money on offer in other Asian leagues,” Arnold said.

That statement alone explains the talent drain to Asia. At the moment it’s a one-way ticket; scribble a number on a piece of paper, make your offer and your player will take off to chase the riches on offer in places like Saudi Arabia, Japan, South Korea or the UAE.

Sure, some players back up the truck; Mark Milligan and Mile Sterjovski are two recent examples of quality Australian talent who have come back the other way, but the lack of Asian-born players willing to come to these shores is concerning.

There are just three Asian players in the Hyundai A-League at this stage: Sydney FC’s Ali Abbas and Hirofumi Moriyasu, and recent Brisbane Roar signing Do Dong-Hyun. It’s hardly a positive representation of our international confederation members but it’s perhaps representative of the standing of our own competition.

In dollar terms, A-League clubs simply cannot complete with the wages most Asian clubs offer, and by moving continents, the players get to prove themselves on a different level for the international set-up, as well as the cultural experience.

But at this stage, it’s a lose/lose situation for the A-League; players are leaving and we’re not getting much in return. It seems a waste of such a rich talent base that could aid the A-League’s technical development.

But how can we compete? There is all kinds of money involved in team ownership in Asia; car production companies own teams, sheiks own teams, oil barons own teams, as do leaders of business.

Surely there are players, even in the lower leagues, that could be tempted by a new competition and different culture. Imports are often keen to say they’re not here for the lifestyle – but let’s be honest, it’s one of our biggest selling points, so let’s use it.

The player drain of course manifests itself in another way and coaches and fans are left asking how do we adequately replace this talent?

For the second time in two seasons the Mariners have now been directly affected.

The loss of Matt Simon and Rostyn Griffiths last year was almost catastrophic, as the goals dried up and the supposed, John Sutton, was a massive failure. Granted, they still won the premiership but the Mariners were a different side once Simon set sail for Korea and not for the better.

The signature of Mile Sterjovski will go some way to replacing Simon, and Arnold might even have a readymade Wilko replacement in youngster Zac Anderson, signed from the defunct Gold Coast United.

With their captain gone and their highly rated goalkeeper in the sights on some massive European teams, Anderson’s ability to develop into a first-team defender becomes one of the most important off-season aims for Arnold.

The burly defender was impressive alongside Michael Thwaite at Gold Coast, but stepping into the shoes of the club’s long-serving captain would be a big ask for anyone.

The Mariners will move on to their next generation but to keep losing your best players must be endlessly frustrating, and because of their small budget this player drain will hurt them more than other, more financially successful clubs.

But how do any of our teams bring Asian talent here? If you have the answer I’d love to know. We don’t have the money and I'm yet to see an Asian player really star over here.

Do we need someone to take a risk or will we always be reliant on the odd South American flair and curious European?

 
The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author, and do not reflect those of Football Federation Australia.
Comments (9)
 
Shenqing chu for Adelaide had one great season, before injury stepped in
Matt  |  
24 Jul 2012 01:46 PM
 
 
To be honest unless the season is extended its always going to be an issue. I completely agree with Ian Crooks comments on players not coping with such a big gap between campaigns and to hold onto the best players they need plenty of game time and clubs need higher crowds plus lets be realistic here, its all about money. Unless A-League clubs can offer the lure of big money contracts players will continue to move on. Look at what is happening in China with the likes of didier drogba completing a move away from the Premier League. Other EPL clubs would have taken him but its all about the money. The same pot of gold is being offered in the Middle East as well. Australia will be a good platform for developing young players but the reality is the money and the opportunity for more game time will be too good to refuse.
Andy  |  
22 Jul 2012 07:51 AM
 
 
I think John has the idea. If an A-League team hoists the Asian Champs League trophy, other players from Asia will come to that team, thinking how good they are. Then they see your country and think, "I'll stay here, but in . . . Melbourne/Newcastle/Perth."
Tony Genualdi  |  
20 Jul 2012 09:18 AM
 
 
Can someone please let us know how much does a young star like Ben Holloran get in the A-League and how much will he get when he gets a contract in Asia or Utrecht sitting on the bench ? Also, how much are the A-League clubs losing in lost ticket sales when we could have bigger crowds with Australian stars playing here like Brosque, Leckie, Oar etc. I would love to see games with Leckie and Oar. That gets me excited and I would go and see more with Aussie players to be honest. I still go, but being honest I like seeing Aussie players. Also, how much would the standard of the league and players have grown if they stayed here ? That would create a sense of feeling of connection with the fans and teams with the same players rather than new teams each year. With bigger crowds could we train them harder like overseas and have crowds like overseas ? AFL does have overseas crowds so why cant we in A-League ?
Lester  |  
20 Jul 2012 12:23 AM
 
 
asian champions leauge, we need to win next year! show were class down here
adl_utd73  |  
19 Jul 2012 07:11 PM
 
 
I wonder how much A-league players earn in a season
Marselinus  |  
19 Jul 2012 05:13 PM
 
 
I think one solution is to adopt the AFC's 3+1 foreigner rule whereby clubs are allowed 3 foreigners without restriction but are allowed to have 4 if at least one of those is from another Asian nation (although here in Australia where the foreigner limit is 5, the rule could be modified to 4+1). That would provide A-League clubs with a greater incentive to sign Asian players, not to mention the fact that it would bring us in line with other Asian leagues.
George  |  
19 Jul 2012 12:18 PM
 
 
I agree it is a problem and one that will always be in football. For example playing in the English Championship and offered a move to the Premiership, money always plays a factor. From living in the Middle East, it is true they have incredible funds but are more likely to invest in foreign leagues such as England & Spain because they are more glamorous, create international profile and provide instant gratification. As a result their domestic league is not growing and they rely on Asians/Aussies, curious Europeans and S Americans. In addition, a heavy reliance on Arab ex-pats because their populations do not exercise never mind play football. Talent is few and far between. I'm afraid like in many AFC territories football will need to continue to gain small wins to progress. in Australia, investment is an issue but the larger one is football being far behind other codes of ball games, something that European and South Americans don't contend with. Great website & blogs by the way
Scal  |  
19 Jul 2012 10:51 AM
 
 
The only solution to attract Asian players here is for our clubs to show thye mean business by dominating the ACL and in turn getting private ownership. The Clive Palmer model may have failed but guys with that kind of money are important for the game to grow.
john  |  
18 Jul 2012 07:12 PM
 
Poll
Which opening round fixture are you most looking forward to?




Paul Johnson

Deputy editor of footballaustralia.com.au, Paul Johnson is an experienced sports journalist and not afraid to share his views on football's most controversial topics.