With just five points from nine games Gold Coast United are seven points away from a top-six spot. If they continue at this rate - which I hope they don’t - they will be completely out of finals contention by January.

Hopefully they can start getting results to keep things alive; if not, it’s over. It will be like a holiday for the players all the way until the first round next season. As I discussed in my previous column, the relegation system though would change this and would make a world of difference.

Of course voices are loud about how it can be done? Who will a relegated team be replaced by? What about potential financial difficulties for relegated teams? Here is my list of potential teams to enter a second division: Western Sydney, Canberra, Wollongong, Tasmania and Geelong.

Our regular Hyundai A-League season runs from October to March, which compared with many other football nations is an extremely short season, resulting in huge issues for our young national teams when they play games out of season.

The home draw for our U23s v UAE a few months back could very well turn out to be the missing points that cost us participation at the London Olympic Games.

Similarly, our Young Socceroos were sent home early in the group stages of the Under-20 World Cup, demolished by Spain in the last game.

There are many reasons for these poor results but the fact that our off-season is so long creates problems in how we keep our boys ticking over at a competitive level and not wilt away.

It’s not just the missing match practice, it’s a mental thing. Preparation for training or a friendly is different; the mind is more relaxed, it’s not a pressure situation - the mind is not on edge, but it has to be to perform on a high level. It’s vital we cater for the needs of our young national teams - the need to keep ticking over and playing official competitive games, not endless friendlies and training camps (which all cost money).

This is where a second division consisting of five teams plus a "relegated" A-league team comes into play. The league could run from April/May-August no A-League players, with the exception being each team would have openings for a number of Young Socceroos and U23s in each squad to keep our boys ticking over at a competitive level-as well as, of course, the home-grown talent in each state.

What happens to the last placed A-League team in March? In school terms it’s called "detention". The student at school has been below-average, needs to stay behind and put in extra hours. Even a scenario where the last two placed teams play off against each other would be a possibility.

The "relegated" A-league team would go straight into the second division -they weren’t able to survive in the top-tier - but instead of banishing them completely, they've been given a lifeline to get back immediately.

It won't be easy though. The second division teams are all ready and raring to go, waiting to sink their teeth into opponents - they want A-League top-tier football as well. It's a race to the A-League.

What about the system for second division? Twenty games, the top team enters a grand final, while second and third contest a playoff. The second and third-placed playoff winner then meets the top team in the grand final - the game that determines who has won the race to the A-League.

This is Australia, we want the thrills and spills of finals football - plus we want to keep all six teams’ chances alive for as long as possible, to try and avoid having games where there’s nothing to play for.

When Swansea played against Reading in such a game in the English Championship last May, 86,500 people flocked to Wembley Stadium. Both sets of fans captivated by it all - and not just the teams’ fans - the whole country. And many other countries in the world, including us in Australia.

There was something serious to play for; it was compelling stuff and those with a real thirst for entertainment (including myself) thrived on witnessing such an event.

Many will ask, "Why Western Sydney in the second division? That’s our footballing heartland". I would love to see them in the A-League, but the Western Sydney bidders couldn’t get their finances together to start up a team, so let them start in the lower tier where budget, expenses, and the wage structure would be much less than A-League levels, giving them a chance to build as a club.

One issue with this model would be what to do with our friends across the Tasman if they finish in a relegation spot? Looks like we’d have to give them a free pass (regrettably) but that’s one that just can’t be avoided. A team from New Zealand playing second division in Australia?. It's far from ideal.

Of course, a favourable new TV deal would be key to putting a relegation system in place and getting a second league off the ground. A solution and pre-requisite for a second tier would have to be free-to-air TV.

Depending on what happens with the new TV deal - irrespective of who gets the rights - some kind of deal would have to be struck to enable free-to-air, giving a wider audience the chance to watch it, similar to the W-League now. It would be a great appetiser for the A-League, creating massive interest and hugely beneficial to the A-League TV rights holder.

Maintaining success and keeping the league alive is, of course, a priority. But evolving and looking to improve should be as well. Adding additional excitement is one of those factors . Sure, I have a real thirst for entertainment, but that is what sport should always be - entertainment.

 
Comments (26)
 
It's time for the federations to go and the state leagues to step up. Lets drop the idea of making teams from scratch. lets give 10 of the best state teams a go in a second division and the rest to make up a semi pro 3rd division.
Luke  |  
29 Dec 2011 07:53 PM
 
 
I dont think relegation would work at this point for some of the same reasons mentioned earlier (Money, Free to Air TV, fan following). An FA Cup style of competition would be needed for the second division teams to become successful. Can have the A-League, NSW Premier League, and other top tier state based teams play in a competition. This would generate support, fans, money and set the ground work for a 2nd division league in Australia if it were to come to that in a few years time. This also promotes the future for the sport with young players coming through the ranks and being able to be scouted by the A-League to make the sport grow stronger. Which will make Australia become a more competitive country in the future.
Kyle  |  
14 Dec 2011 08:57 AM
 
 
with some reservations i say yes - but i would like first to see AUSTRALIA CUP COMPETITION. for some reason very quiet - dead idea??
Lubanski  |  
13 Dec 2011 03:56 PM
 
 
The ideas of entertainment , learning and teaching all deal with a couple of concepts the ability to communicate , demonstrate and enunciate a working deliverable model of football performance. Ned , it matters not that a promotion or relegation strategy , we have been told we cant afford such a luxury and so we need to look at a variation . Arnold and Postecoglou have a model that works in a tight competition . One day franchises , FFA or a privateer will see the merit of development resources books , DVDs , CDROMs that expand the Australian football fan skill set as well as the working stakeholders.
Tony  |  
13 Dec 2011 03:18 PM
 
 
I completely agree.. a second division would raise the intensity, therefore raising the quality of play, therefore raising interest, then attendances, so on, so forth.. The idea of the second tier taking place in the off season may not be so wise though as it would tire out the relegated team and also limit time for promoted teams to enhance their squad for the next tier. Relegated teams should also be automatically replaced with new teams, giving them an entire season to feel the pain. I agree with keeping this A2-league small and low-profit though, with low salary caps, however a set amount of revenue to help promoted sides should be put aside..
Nicholas  |  
13 Dec 2011 01:59 AM
 
 
To be honest, I would prefer the second division to run parallel to the A-League (from October to April, not April to October) like in England. I think 8 teams could be created from Australia and New Zealand. Hobart, Geelong, Canberra, Wollongong, West Sydney, North Queensland, Auckland and Christchurch, with further expansion to Launceston, Central QLD and maybe the Pacific nations. A simple 1-up 1-down method could be the trick, and use the old A-League final 4 system.
Jordan  |  
12 Dec 2011 09:43 PM
 
 
The idea of a second division sounds amazing and having it on free-to-air tv is incredible. All i wanted since I started loving the a-league I always wanted it on free TV but they never did. So to have entertaining football on free TV would be a dream come true.
adam  |  
12 Dec 2011 09:53 AM
 
 
Three quarters of the clubs in the AFl and most of the NRL clubs aren't financialy viable and yet we think in Australia we can have a two division football competition! Sorry but while some clubs can't even get 5000 to a game there is no way Australia can sustain a two tiered A-legue competition
Bruce  |  
11 Dec 2011 08:01 PM
 
 
Split it into two 8 team divisions. The additional six teams could come from Western Sydney, Hobart, Townsville, Canberra, Woolongong and Auckland (Or even a third Melbourne/Geelong team). At the end of each season the bottom two teams from the A-League play off in a round robin against the top two from the 'B-League' for a place in the following season's A-League. This still leaves relative stability for the league with a maximum of one team changing each year, but will see teams trying to avoid bottom place. Teams that have had financial troubles in the past can play in the bottom division off a lower cost base (Auckland, North Queensland come to mind) and have the chance to build a club over the years. A requirement in the B-League would be a number of players must be under 23 so this can be a bridge between the youth league and the A-League.
Brodie  |  
11 Dec 2011 07:25 PM
 
 
Ned, you are totally correct on the need for a seecond division. I have given this some thougth myself & this is what I have come up with. The last two on the ladder drop off & enter their respective state competitions. The top team from that particular state league enters the a league. For instance if Sydney Fc are at the bottom of the ladder the top team from the NSW enters the a league and Sydney Fc joins the NSW Premiser league. This keeps the cost down and really revs up the state premier leagues as well. New Zealand could be the one exception however i am sure their are teams in the New Zealand that would gladly join. Each new team would have to be given money to cope with the travel.
greg w  |  
11 Dec 2011 09:17 AM
 
 
Football doesn't yet have the following here in Australia, plus the travel distances are too great/costly. I think what the FFA has done is recent years has been positive and football within Australia is developing nicely (A-League, ACL, etc). Do we really need to follow the promotion/relegation system of Europe? I think our system is fine (for the time being anyhow) and before looking at promotion/relegation we should be looking at an FA Cup type knockout competition involving the State League clubs, which might eventually get an opportunity to play against the A-League clubs, etc. And finally, considering the issues in Europe, I wouldn't be in a rush to follow anything they're doing at the moment....... :P
Brad  |  
11 Dec 2011 02:13 AM
 
 
Money is a problem due to the wrong choice when first starting out. Should have gone free to air until the following was there or similar to the NRL with free to air and pay TV. Also if money is not there then expanding the A League will result in more teams folding as it will cause increased travel cost. Australia does need a 2nd Division or B League of some sort. May be a State run league for each state, with the top 2 teams from each state league involved in a play off to replace the one or maybe two relegated teams from the A League with them teams returning to their state league. May be then the state league could have relegation of teams and promotion of other teams from the next best leagues in the state; this would keep the travel cost down. Something similar to the way the NFL in America do there conferences. We need to do some thing as the cost for the kids to play football $300 to $400+ compaired to $80 to $180 for other codes will turn the parents away. And the cost for the
Mark  |  
10 Dec 2011 09:53 PM
 
 
I reckon that a second division is a great idea but incorporate the state champion from each state and use that as the the second division. I understand that names and feeder clubs may come into some sort of contradiction but it could still work out. At least the would be representation from every state then.
CALVIN  |  
10 Dec 2011 08:59 PM
 
 
Ned, sorry but Robbo and James from Sydney have it spot on. The travel expenses around this country for the quality of game and number of supporters just does not add up and will not for many years to come. Has there ever been a second division in Australia? Has AFL even had it?? VFL is a good concept but it's only state wide. As a soccer player, I can say that the current game needs a lot more work in terms of quality and entertainment before it can expand anyway. Marquee players are ok if they perform but it's ultimately good coaches and good youth systems that will build this game and the future! Oh and free to AIR!!
Dejan from Melbourne  |  
10 Dec 2011 07:44 PM
 
 
Can't possibly work, for all the reasons put to you before, the main one being money (or lack of it). No second division will generate sufficient interest to be viable. The only way forward is controlled expansion of the A-League in due course, plus an FFA Cup.
jonny  |  
10 Dec 2011 04:43 PM
 
 
The idea has some merit but why are we always looking at new start up teams. We have a number of state league clubs with the infrastructure to slot striaght in to a second division. Two such teams are playing a 'friendly' game today in Melbourne to open a sparkling, new stadium. I know, I know...old soccer versus new football is still alive and kicking!!!!
Phil K  |  
10 Dec 2011 12:44 PM
 
 
I don't actually agree that such a small league could exist with any fans caring about it in the off season. Simply a second division could exist and run simultaneously with the first division from October to March. Small towns have big passion behind local teams so why doesn't FFA make a complete overhaul of football and make 4 divisions within a country. Teams would range from range from Sydney to Bundaberg, Melbourne to Gympie, this would truly get everyone in Australia involved in the game. Each tier should have 16 teams, so to begin with the A-League would need to expand in my opinion to Tasmania, Western Sydney, Geelong, Auckland, Canberra and Southern Sydney.
Sam  |  
9 Dec 2011 10:16 PM
 
 
Something to aim for...I think a first step though might be to start up a cup competition with some of these potential teams taking part. This would allow a couple of years for them to build a base of support. Coming from Geelong, I would love to see a local team in the competition, and there is no reason why they could not build up a base of a few thousand supporters down here.
Michael H  |  
9 Dec 2011 06:18 PM
 
 
Like the idea but still think we should have 2 leagues running from October to May consisting of 12 teams in each with the top five from the both divisions all qualifying for a finals series where 2nd vs 3rd and 4th vs 5th the winner of 2nd vs 3rd vs 1st to host the grand final and the loser players the winner of the loser of 2nd vs 3rd and the winner of 4th vs 5th with the champion of league 2 promoted and last place of league one demoted also the top 4 or 3 of division 1 should be put in the ACL
Mitch  |  
9 Dec 2011 05:56 PM
 
 
Sure, promotion/relegation would be a great idea, I'd love it, but it just can't work in Australia. You need two things for it to be economically viable: - Small country with teams close together - An overly dominant sport which is far more popular than the other sports, so there is still interest in teams that aren't at the top level. We don't have either of these things. Imagine flying a squad like Perth away to Gold Coast or Melbourne every second week to play in front of a crowd of 1,100 and very low tv ratings... where does the money come from ?
Robbo  |  
9 Dec 2011 05:29 PM
 
 
Like the model for the second division, but if we go with FTA, Fox doesn't fork out the money, money is vital right now.
Chris  |  
9 Dec 2011 04:53 PM
 
 
This is a really exciting concept. The ONLY thing I would ask is... why Wollongong? If Sydney were the A-League wooden spooners, there'd be no representation at all from WA, SA or Queensland, which is a little exclusive... isn't it? I fully understand the strategic reasoning for Western Sydney, Canberra, Tasmania and Geelong (Tassie REALLY deserve a team), but surely the fifth team must be North Adelaide? There's already a base for them at Burton Park, where the Lady Reds play their home games.
Sam Aukland  |  
9 Dec 2011 04:37 PM
 
 
A lot of good points, but I think promotion/relegation is still at least 5 or so years off. Consolidation is the key and it's starting to happen the standards getting better, crowds are up and we are attracting bigger names which means more bums on seats!
Nic  |  
9 Dec 2011 04:28 PM
 
 
I dont watch the A-league exactly for that reason, what's the point when there's no relegation and promotion. Football is all about fighting to stay up and fighting againts relegation,that's what gives it its charm.Thats why I stick to VPL,it has a purpose and knew exciting teams entering every year. I hope the A-league can process a second division.
Marin Zun  |  
9 Dec 2011 04:21 PM
 
 
Actially i totally agree a second division could give the lower clubs something to play for, it works overseas why not give it a go here id actually go to these games just to see the up and coming talent
steven  |  
9 Dec 2011 04:10 PM
 
 
Great read Ned. I firmly believe a second division is something we should strive to have but right now shouldn't we be consolidating our position as a sport??????
James from Sydney  |  
9 Dec 2011 01:16 PM
 
Poll
Who is Australia's best young prospect?